How to validate your marketplace idea before building the platform

published on 26 June 2023

When you embark on the journey of creating your own marketplace business, it's crucial to recognize the importance of validating your marketplace idea and ensuring it has a viable business model. As an aspiring entrepreneur, you may have already conducted extensive research and gained valuable insights from the previous chapters of this guide on creating a marketplace. Now, you have reached a point where your marketplace idea has crystallized and you have chosen a suitable business model.

While you may be eager to launch your marketplace platform as soon as possible, it's essential to take a step back and realize that the final validation of your business will occur after the platform is launched and people start using it. Before you dive into writing code or hiring a marketplace developer, it's crucial to undertake certain prevalidation steps. These steps allow you to validate various assumptions about your idea and business model without even having a platform in place. By doing so, you can increase your chances of building a successful marketplace. In this text, we will delve into why and how you should approach prevalidation.

Why you need to validate your marketplace idea

Let's reflect on a couple of real-life examples that highlight the importance of validating your marketplace idea. In one case, a startup focused on developing a music quiz platform invested significant time, effort, and resources into building the platform. Despite attending networking events and pitching to potential investors, they struggled to engage users in the way they had envisioned. By the time they realized the platform was not working as expected, it was too late to pivot, resulting in the project's failure.

Similarly, in another instance, an entrepreneur with an idea for a marketplace platform dedicated to helping individuals assist each other encountered significant challenges. They devoted countless hours to learning and building the platform but eventually discovered that their product did not genuinely address a pressing problem for their users. Unfortunately, they had wasted substantial time and effort during the development process.

These experiences are not isolated incidents. Many marketplace entrepreneurs have faced similar struggles, often resulting from the failure to validate their core assumptions. It's a common mistake to overlook the importance of validating your business idea and strategy. In fact, it is arguably the most critical error budding marketplace entrepreneurs make. As emphasized in the earlier chapters of this guide, many startup teams end up developing what can be referred to as "desert platforms" – platforms that are well-built but fail to gain traction. This usually stems from a lack of validation of the business idea and strategy.

Entrepreneurs often fall into the trap of becoming enamored with their own ideas. They may disregard user feedback, particularly if it conflicts with their original concept. This phenomenon, known as the "entrepreneur illusion," can be detrimental to the success of your marketplace. It's important to recognize that no amount of hard work can salvage an idea that lacks viability.

Maximize value, not output

Rather than fixating solely on maximizing output, it is crucial to focus on maximizing value. Agile and lean coach Henrik Kniberg has aptly captured this concept in a presentation, which I highly recommend exploring. By prioritizing value over sheer output, you can ensure that your marketplace delivers a meaningful and satisfying experience to both buyers and sellers.

What you should validate

Venture capitalist Marc Andreessen rightly emphasizes that, initially, the most crucial factor is finding product/market fit. This means being in a favorable market with a product that effectively satisfies the existing demand. Startup guru Steve Blank further breaks down this concept into two steps: customer discovery and problem/solution fit.

Before diving into building the Minimum Viable Product (MVP) or Minimum Viable Platform, it is crucial to focus on achieving problem/solution fit. This involves identifying and understanding the core problems your marketplace aims to solve. By the end of this stage, you should have clarity on the most critical problem(s) and how your platform will address them.

To prevalidate your marketplace idea, you can utilize various tools and techniques. One of the most popular and effective tools is the Customer-Problem-Solution Hypothesis, as presented in "The Entrepreneur's Guide to Customer Development." This hypothesis helps structure your validation efforts by breaking down the assumptions you need to validate into three main components: the customer, the problem, and the solution. By systematically testing and validating these assumptions, you can refine your marketplace idea and build a more robust business model.

Two useful tools for capturing and validating your marketplace assumptions are the Business Model Canvas (BMC) and the Platform Design Canvas. These frameworks provide a visual representation of your business model, allowing you to map out the key elements and relationships. By using these tools, you can identify assumptions specific to marketplace platforms, such as the target customer segments, the value proposition, and the revenue streams.

Recommended resources for validating your marketplace idea

To deepen your understanding of validating business models and marketplace assumptions, we highly recommend reading Eric Ries' influential book, "The Lean Startup." This book has sparked a movement in the startup world, emphasizing the importance of validated learning, iterative development, and continuous improvement. Ries presents valuable insights and practical techniques to help entrepreneurs navigate the uncertain and challenging terrain of startups.

Another valuable resource is Ash Maurya's book, "Running Lean." Maurya provides a step-by-step guide to building successful internet companies while operating on a limited budget. He introduces a systematic framework for testing assumptions, conducting experiments, and gathering feedback from customers. By following Maurya's approach, you can optimize your marketplace development process and reduce the risk of building a product that fails to gain traction.

Validating assumptions in practice: A personal trainer marketplace example

To illustrate the process of validating assumptions in a marketplace context, let's consider an example of a marketplace for personal trainer services. Suppose you have identified a potential opportunity in this market and want to validate your assumptions before investing in platform development. Here's how you can approach it:

  1. Interviewing potential users: One of the most effective methods for gaining insights and validating assumptions is by conducting interviews with potential customers and providers. Craft a set of open-ended questions to understand their experiences, challenges, and needs related to personal trainer services. Actively listen to their responses and look for patterns or common pain points that emerge.
  2. Studying search data: In addition to interviews, analyzing search data can provide valuable insights into market demand. Utilize tools like Semrush to examine keyword search volumes related to personal trainer services. This analysis can help validate assumptions about user behavior, popular search terms, and the overall market size.

By combining qualitative data from interviews with quantitative data from search analysis, you can gain a comprehensive understanding of the market, validate your assumptions, and make informed decisions about your marketplace idea.

Prioritizing validation for marketplace success

Validating your marketplace assumptions is a critical step in ensuring the success of your platform. By following effective strategies such as prevalidation, user interviews, and studying search data, you can gather valuable insights and make informed decisions before investing in platform development. Remember to prioritize value creation over sheer output and focus on achieving problem/solution fit. By understanding the needs of your target users and addressing their core problems, you can build a marketplace that resonates with both buyers and sellers and drives traction for your platform.

Read more

Built on Unicorn Platform